Wednesday, March 23, 2011

The Minifigures Are The Point

7930 Bounty Hunter Assult Gunship
The Chronicler's Rating - 2/5
Price ~ $50.00
Year Released - 2011

This set is difficult to review because the point of it is not the ship, the point is the minifigures.  For all practical purposes the ship is ancillary.  This set is a perfect example of a trend which started just before the advent of the Lego Star Wars series in the late 90's and has now grown into a whole segment of Lego’s product line: minifigures as collectibles.  The Lego Company tried it first with sports figures; you used to be able to get sets with a collection of basketball players and their associated cards.  The idea was that Lego could charge more because the minifigures were "one of a kind" and you couldn't get them in any other set.    The Bounty Hunter Assault Gunship is employing this same strategy, albeit on a slightly larger scale.

 This ship, out of necessity, employs what I call the “scaled down technique”.  What this entails is taking a ship that is quite large and making it into a model of much smaller size and scale.  There is absolutely nothing wrong with this technique, it has allowed from some wonderful sets (2006’s 6211 Imperial Star Destroyer comes to mind).  I love what this building style allows for the problem here is that due to the collectable figures the price feels very inflated for the size of the ship that you get.  The pictures are a bit misleading in reality it is no bigger than a fighter.  I have many ships in my collection that were under $20.00 that are the same size as this. 

FOR PARENTS
If your child is a Star Wars fan and really wants these minifigures my suggestion would be to wait and see if an cheaper way to acquire them comes along (Lego will often follow these "one of a kind" sets with smaller cheaper ways of getting the desired minifigures).  This review is being written in March of 2011 so if it is significantly later than that I would check.  If no other option is available, and your child is not set on having these 4 figures, I would suggest you spend your money elsewhere.  The reason for this is 2 fold.  First, the number of pieces you get for the price is not very good on this set (again remember the point is the collectible minifigures so this makes sense).  Secondly, Lego sets inevitably get taken apart and your child uses the pieces for their own creations.  Dark green (the predominant color in this set) is rare and it will be difficult for your child to use these pieces for anything else, their color inhibits their versatility.  However, if your child is a fan of these figures and the ship those two points will not matter much so go for it. 

FOR KIDS
This is a fairly expensive Lego set.  If you are a fan of the Star Wars movies and TV show where this ship appears and really want to be able to have adventures that include capturing Jedi Knights with these 4 bounty hunters then this will be a great set for you.  If the idea of a prison ship is what makes you excited about it I would suggest looking at the Space Police sets instead as their prisons are cooler and you get more for your money. 

CONCLUSION
When I was a kid Lego minifigures were all very simple.  They all had the same smiley face and wore very simple accessories.  In light of that I must confess that the idea of a minifigure being the reason you buy a Lego set doesn’t make sense to me (in that I recognize that I differ from many Lego enthusiasts, too each their own).  If that is something that you enjoy and is a major goal of your collection then this is the set for you.  If you are looking for a versatile set that is also a good deal I would look elsewhere. 

Happy Building
TheLegoChronicler

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

A Funny And Eventful Trip To The Lego Store...

While at a training conference I decided to have a look at Disneyland which was located right across the street from my hotel.  This fairly simple mission turned into a very funny episode.

I had no previous knowledge of the area so I just followed the fence until I saw what appeared to be the entrance.  As I was exploring the area around the monorail I came across the very large Lego store that is part of the “Downtown Disney” complex which is a large shopping area just outside the gates which is open to the public.  As I had not been in such a store since my dad and I went to Mall of America back in I believe 1995 and I had time to spare I went in.  My childlike enjoyment in looking at models created by the Lego Masters has apparently not abated and I was enjoying myself substantially as I did a lap around the perimeter of the shop.  In most respects it was nearly identical to the Mall of America store, dioramas of recent sets, colorful displays and the requisite life size Darth Vader model with sound effects and all.  However, as I came to the back of the store I observed something that had not been in my previous Lego Store experience.  It was called the Pick-A-Brick wall.  I immediately saw the genius of it.  In an alcove 20 feet wide the wall was lined with probably 30 wall mounted containers each housing thousands of loose bricks (each bin with its own type of brick).  It was obviously modeled after a candy store as the bricks were of a variety of shapes and colors.  I passed a quick critical eye over the offerings and my 23 years of training allowed me to quickly see what was going on here.  Whoever came up with this was a genius, the potential for ripping off unsuspecting parents was almost a guarantee.  The offerings were haphazard at best and almost unethical at worst, I immediately for example spotted the cabinet door pieces, without the matching cabinet pieces being offered (yay little Jonny can have 50 cabinet doors!) and, I kid you not half of a hinge piece.  Most of the other bins contained brightly colored but very small pieces (headlights in 6 different colors took up 6 of the bins) obviously meant for little hands to run around enamored with the colors and the ability to take handfuls of what would prove to be worthless bricks later on while parents who didn’t know any better watched oblivious.  With the delight of the kids and the obliviousness of the parents I suppose it all works out as the majority of the pieces being offered must cost Lego less than a penny to produce so everyone wins in their minds. 

Having surveyed this I asked the next logical question: how does this system work, namely how are the pieces quantified?  By weight?  By (God forbid) counting?  Then I saw the display and the cups.  Yes it was by cup, essentially an all you can eat Lego café.  Whatever you could get into one of the two cup sizes (small and large) you got to take.  As I mentally saluted Lego for their brilliant money making scheme and turned to go I noticed a bin at the bottom… and stopped in my tracks.  Surely this must have been a mistake.  To understand my shock you must understand a basic about Lego building.  When you go to buy a Lego set what you see on the box is the “final layer” if you will.  Every set contains on their outermost cool looking pieces that add detail and character.  But beneath those are two basic kinds of bricks: blocks and plates.  In order to build any sort of large model you have to have a ton of those two types in various sizes.  Small blocks and plates are easily found but the large ones mean dropping at a minimum $50 on a set, anything smaller just doesn’t get large enough to require them.  This is especially true of plates.  The holy grail of Lego plates is the 6x16 stud plate and to get one of those you are going to have to drop some serious coin.  I collected Lego sets my entire childhood (and in the interest of honesty perhaps a set or two or 10 or 20 after my childhood that I thought was really cool even as an adult…) and have maybe 25 of them.  Or shall I say that was as many as I had before yesterday. 

Yes in that bottom bin, and in the basic universal grey color (thank God not the new puke green), were 6x16 plates.  I couldn’t believe it.  Realizing this was a chance to add sizeable capital to my collection and allow my own kids to more easily create mammoth creations I grabbed one of the large cups and surveyed it.  About that time one of the employees came up.  Apparently it is a rare thing to have someone my age not accompanied by a kid in the pick-a-brick section.  We ended up talking and I explained how I had been collecting for over 2 decades etc.  He was genuinely interested and asked me a variety of questions.  At the end of the conversation he, noticing the large cup in my hand, informed me that the bricks did not have to be loose in the cup as I had assumed.  So real quick let me sum up the components of this situation:

Engineer + Rare Rectangular Plate Bricks + Round Cup = Craziness

I started building.  The cup was designed so as to make the user fail.  It was noticeably larger at the top than the bottom, purposefully structured to be as unreceptive to square and rectangular shapes as possible.  Fortunately when I was about 13 I embarked to mimic the Lego Masters by building round shapes, and I had gotten fairly decent at it.  Over the next hour (yes I stood there for that long) I constructed what ultimately amounted to a plug.  Like the engineer’s in Apollo 13 I constructed a round shape out of square objects to go into a round hole.  When I finished it had packed that space so perfectly that it almost didn’t make that “Lego Brick” noise when shaken despite the loose bricks I had packed into the empty spaces and was in so tight that if you flipped it upside down nothing fell out. 

But what made it interesting and ultimately hilarious was that I drew a crowd.  Kids curious about what I was doing came to watch.  Parents followed.  I started giving advice on what bricks were deals and what ones were not.  Kids began to consult with me on their selections before putting them in their cups and dads started copying some of the shapes I was constructing.  Lego should have given me a commission I sold so many of those cups.  Parents who would not have bought grabbed cups and others who were just going to get one got two.  I got question after question, it was like I had my own production in that little alcove, one set of parents even asked me to pose with their kid for a picture each holding our cups.  More and more people came over to see what was going on, it was crazy.  Parents were calling me the Lego Master Guy.  It was a lot of fun.

In the end I walked out with two of these cups ($16 a cup).  When I got back to the hotel room I just had to know how good of a deal I had gotten.  As it turned out I blew even my own expectations.  I knew that Lego has the pick-a-brick wall equivalent on their website.  The selection is far more vast but of course online the cost is by count not by cupful.  I counted the pieces and found that I had packed over 50 of those plates into my cups and with the other select pieces I had chosen to fill in the empty spaces, walked out of there with just under 1000 bricks.  But the kicker was when I entered those bricks into the website.  If I had bought the same lot of bricks online it would have cost over $180.00 and it cost me only $32.00.  On second thought maybe Lego shouldn’t have given me a commission as I coached a bunch of parents on how to do the same thing…

When Compared With Past Stations One Of The Best

7498 Police Station
The Chronicler's Rating - 4/5
Price ~ $100.00
Year Released - 2011

For the past 20+ years Lego has released, without fail, a new police station every 3 to 5 years.  Some have been excellent (1993's Central Precinct HQ), others have been terrible (1998's Command Post Central) with most falling somewhere in the middle (1996's Metro PD Station for example).  I am pleased to say that Lego has done very well with this installment, when compared to its many predecessors it emerges near the top of the list. 

This set draws obvious inspiration from its immediate predecessor, 2008’s 7744 Police Headquarters.  Most notably the dual jail cells, lower level garages, the color scheme and the included vehicles.  However, this station is not a copy and has some very distinctive features.  This set represents, as far as I can remember, an original concept in terms of city buildings.  The L shaped design joined by curved windows is an architectural feature that has not appeared in any other Lego City building to date.  I must say with how pleasing it is to the eye I hope Lego continues with this type of construction!  It is also a full honest to goodness 3 stories which puts it into very exclusive company (most 3 story buildings have a single room at the top, this has a whole floor).  7744 Police Headquarters was 3 stories but the bottom was garages which don’t, in my mind, count.  In terms of number of rooms I think only the Central Precinct HQ had more, making this one of the largest police station sets ever.    

FOR PARENTS
If your child loves the City theme you can't go wrong with a police station and you can have peace of mind buying this one knowing it is one of the best thus far released by Lego.  The only stations that I would say are better than this one are 6398 Central Precinct HQ and 7744 Police Station.  The playability of this set is such that it will provide many happy hours of play for your money and it has good pieces that can be used by your child easily in the construction of their own creations.       

FOR KIDS
No city collection is complete without a police station.  I myself have 3 of them in my collection, a main headquarters and 2 smaller auxiliary stations.  If you enjoy the city theme this would be a great set to add to your collection.

CONCLUSION
 No City collection is complete without a police station.  Having lived through most of the previous offerings you won't do much better than this one.  The only major demerit is that the price to piece ratio is worse than most previous sets; in other words you are getting a bit less for your money as far as the piece count.  Lego appears to have stretched those fewer pieces well though as I don't see anything major that this set is missing which others had.  Kudos to the designer. 

Happy Building
TheLegoChronicler


Tuesday, March 8, 2011

An Old Tactic Revisited

2504 Spinjitzu Dojo
The Chronicler's Rating - 4/5
Price ~ $50.00
Year Released - 2011


With the Ninjago theme Lego resurrected a design tactic which was most prevalent in the late 90s and first few years of the 2000's (primarily with the Lego Sports theme): blurring the line between set and game.  The general gist of this tactic is that every set is designed to both be a standard Lego model used to act out adventures and stories from a child's imagination as well as an actual game with rules that children can compete in.  As I mentioned the heyday of this approach was the Lego Sports theme (which included soccer, basketball, hockey and more) in which the sets depicted sports venues but also contained special elements which actually allowed balls (or pucks) to be passed and shot.  The child didn't just have to act out a soccer match, they could actually compete in one with their friends.  The spinners included with this and many of the other Nijago sets are designed to allow minifigures to actually "battle" by using the spinning action imparted by the players to knock the weapons out of the hand of the opposing minifigure, imagine dueling, spinning tops and you will have the idea.  So the set can be played with normally or used as a game board to compete with friends.

Creating this type of set requires that the designer maintain a very delicate balance.  Making a set both an enjoyable play piece and an amusing game is a tall order and very often the old adage of "something that tries to do everything does nothing well" is proven as one aspect is sacrificed for the sake of the other.  I am pleased to say however that Lego appears to have walked the line well with most of the Ninjago sets including this one. 

FOR PARENTS
The beauty of this type of set is that it appeals to a wider audience.  Growing up I had a sibling who was a sports fanatic.  Quite often the standard Lego set does not appeal to his kind of personality which always wants to be competing.  This type of set bridges that gap while also appealing to someone like me who enjoys the more traditional style of Lego play involving imagining your own adventures by oneself or with friends.  The only caution I would give is this, the value of this set in terms of pieces per dollar is low.  This is very standard with this sort of set because the pieces needed to create the game aspect are often specialized and more expensive to produce.  If value is your primary objective look elsewhere but if you are mainly concerned with playability look no further, this set is a safe bet.

FOR KIDS
If you like to imagine great adventure stories or to compete in games with your friends this set will be a great addition to your collection.  If however you are the type that puts together a set once and then takes it apart to use the parts for your own creations I would recommend that you look for a set that has more and better pieces than this one.  Also, be aware that it only comes with one spinner so if you actually want to have 2 minifigures compete you are going to need to get an additional set that contains a second spinner.

Happy Building
CONCLUSION
Lego made a bold gamble with the Ninjago sets.  I am happy to report that for the most part the theme and this set especially appear to have walked the fine line of making both a rich play experience and a decent game.   The only problem I have with this set is that it is what I call a Façade set meaning that it isn’t a complete building but more of a wall, like a set piece one would see at a theatre production.  This type of set didn’t exist when I was a kid, everything was a complete building so ultimately this set seems incomplete to me, however, I recognize that this does not steal from the play experience very much (you can after all just image the rest of the building) so the set still gets high marks.

TheLegoChronicler       

Monday, March 7, 2011

A Worthy Successor

7327 Scorpion Pyramid
The Chronicler's Rating - 5/5
Price ~ $100.00
Year Released - 2011

The Pharaoh’s Quest series is unabashedly inspired by the Adventurers theme which began in the late 90's.  I would even go so far as to say it is a continuation of that theme, just with different characters.  This comes as no surprise, the Adventurers theme eventually went on to contain 4 subthemes (these subthemes were locations where the treasure hunting took place and included Egypt, the Amazon, Dino Island and the Orient) and last longer than almost any theme other than the four core themes (Town/City, Space, Pirate and Castle).  I am happy to say that the Pharaoh’s quest sets and the Scorpion Pyramid in particular appear to be worthy successors. 

FOR PARENTS
You pretty much can't go wrong with this set.  Lego is incorporating what has emerged as a winning strategy in the last decade: including both bad guy and good guy components in the same set.  In earlier days it used to be that good guys and bad guys were separate, if you wanted opposing forces it meant spending more money on multiple sets.  A few sets mixed the two but it did not become standardized until the advent of Star Wars.  This formula requires a delicate balance as one portion will often come at the expense of another (the Space Police sets of 2009 and 2010 suffer from this: the bad guy vehicles are fairly Spartan as compared to the very well equipped Space Police Vehicles).  There is a little bit of that here as a lot of the pyramid's baseplate is empty and the inside is fairly puny in comparison to some of its predecessors (5988 Pharaoh’s Forbidden Ruins for example).  This is however of little consequence for one simple reason: everything your kid (or grandkid) needs to start playing is here.  Good guys, bad guys, a giant scorpion, vehicles, weapons and plenty of space for the opposing forces to duke it out.  The playability of this set is excellent and won't disappoint.  If you want a safe bet go with this one.

FOR KIDS
If you were either too young or just didn't get any of the earlier Adventurer's sets I would highly suggest that you consider this one.  The beauty of this type of set (where the point is treasure hunting) is that unless you think some of the other sets are really cool you really only need one.  Inevitably the smaller sets become stops along the treasure hunt which will end right here with this set.  If you think you will only be able to get one of these I would highly recommend that you save up for this one.  If however this is too expensive almost any story you would want to play with this set can be played with 7326 Rise of the Sphinx. 

CONCLUSION
The Adventurers theme was exceptional as proven by its longevity.  This was because its playability was so high.  Many hours of fun could be had and the same is true of this new Pharaoh’s Quest theme and this set in particular.  I highly recommend collecting this theme and especially if you can afford it this set, you won't be disappointed.

Happy Building
TheLegoChronicler